Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
Group Info Group Founded 4 Years ago Statistics 1,405 Members
27,491 Pageviews1,167 Watchers
Hello to All the fab members of IWantFeedback!

It's time you were all reminded that we're not just about getting, but giving feedback. Which is why we have  decided to organize a contest for those who give the best feedback.

How to Enter:

:bulletgreen: It is as simple as taking time out of your day to give feedback to somebody from the IWantFeedback group. Post feedback on their work.
:bulletgreen: Then if they nominate your feedback then you become a particpant of the contest and enter the draw to win.


:bulletgreen: The feedback has to be given to a deviation in our gallery.
:bulletgreen: The nominated deviant has to be part of our group.


In all of our deviations, you’ll see the artist’s description has a section basically telling, “what the artist wants feedback on”. This will help people that are giving feedback know what to focus on.
Those who will be nominating have to take into account that good feedback is not only pointing out the defects/complimenting on what was done well but is also telling the artist how to fix them.
The feedback doesn't have to be huge or to be 4 paragraphs long. Just enough to be able to help the artist.

How to Nominate Someone:

:bulletgreen: Write in the comment section of this journal the following information:
Feedback giver: (link to the person’s profile)
Deviation where feedback was given: (link to the deviation)

Good luck to all.
We will update this journal with prizes soon and also the end date which has not yet been decided.

In the mean time, if anyone can donate points, journal features or drawings as prizes for the contest we would appreciate it.
Thank you all :rose:


:bulletgreen: Feature in the Group
:bulletgreen: a drawing commission from Alrathi
:bulletgreen: sketch commision from rafagranaa


Meekochan :iconmeekochan:
More Journal Entries


Tutorials by anyone, for anyone! They can provide great feedback if you're unsure how to do certain things, including critique.





:bulletblue: Coloured linearts are approved, so long as the original, uncoloured lineart was used with permission from the original artist. (stock linearts, etc. are fine, but must be linked)

:bulletblue: Drawings using bases or character creators will be denied.

:bulletblue: Sketchdumps will be denied; if you want critique on all the drawings, you may send each of them individually.

:bulletblue: Your submission's descriptions will need to include why you want critique or advice on the artwork and/or what about the artwork you would like critique or advice on. If you do not include this, your submission will be denied.

:bulletblue: Traced-over or redrawn manga pages or panels will be denied.

:bulletred: Needless to say, journals of all kinds are denied.
:bulletred: Deviations where feedback cannot be given, due to you disabling comments, will be DENIED.

:bulletgreen: Please also note that submissions to the featured folder will be closed until further notice. Your artwork should be submitted to the appropriate category.









Add a Comment:
FlashtheGecko186 Apr 2, 2014  Student Filmographer
Is my Deviation ready for submission?
I tried to post it in one you galleries, but it isn't going through.
NekoGothWolf Feb 2, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Hi =^-^= Just finished this last night, and was wondering if it's ready for submission?

It's the first page of my comic, and getting comments means a whole lot more to me than favorites because I want motivation then just looking through my messages and finding tons of favs that mean little to me *makes me think people just favorited it in their messages then actually looked at it before faving* .
Rename your useless group into "IWantCritique", idiots.
Hi, i submitted this one:…

Off course, i want feedback, because i work very hard for these, and people only says in my profile "continue it, continue it!".

If i have to feedback otherīs work i will for sure.
RaymondGD Nov 19, 2013  Professional Interface Designer
hackeye Nov 25, 2013   Traditional Artist
Hey there!
I you want to submit into this group feel free to jion! I took a look at your piece and please be sure to include a discribtion of WHAT you want critique before you submit into the group otherwise it will be denied. Check out the rules to get further  information what you need to do to get your art accepted!

Have a nice day!
Sincerely Sergit
TheFS Aug 25, 2013  Hobbyist Writer
Hello everyone in IWantFeedback!

I am currently offering a speed critiquing service for those who want to get professional standard feedback on their prose writing/or poems at a cheap price. I've just finished my latest 45,000 editing/proofreading job and I'm looking for new works!

You could have your short story, the first chapter of your novel or one-act script read by the end of the day with in depth feedback on how to improve!

If you're interested in finding out more, follow the link to my job service forum post.

I look forward to hearing from you! =D
FlashtheGecko186 Jun 27, 2013  Student Filmographer
Does this look ready for submission?
hackeye Jul 9, 2013   Traditional Artist
Seems good to me ^^
FlashtheGecko186 Jul 9, 2013  Student Filmographer
Add a Comment: